-
sech1
There is specialized hardware for CN/R, I'm sure now
-
sech1
Sumokoin nonce distribution chart:
i.imgur.com/C9eFmD6.png
-
sech1
They stayed on CN/R, red line marks when Monero forked to RandomX
-
hyc
hm? the nonce distribution looks more uniform after the fork
-
hyc
well - one obvious division in the nonces, but the two halves have no obvious streaks
-
hyc
what happened between blocks 270000 and 280000?
-
sech1
it's not any of existing GPU miner software for sure
-
sech1
270-280k - it forked to CN/R
-
sech1
neither any proxies produce such nonce pattern, so remnant botnets mining through proxies are also out of the equation
-
hyc
so you're suggesting that CNR ASICs left Monero and jumped onto Sumo after the randomX hardfork?
-
sech1
yes
-
sech1
probably FPGAs
-
sech1
-
sech1
Vega GPU spends 2 times more on power than it earns from mining
-
hyc
got a hashrate chart for them around that time?
-
sech1
hmm
-
sech1
I can add it to the picture
-
sech1
I have full "get_block_headers_range" json RPC output from sumo daemon
-
hyc
that 2:1 cost is pretty nasty. So are Sumo miners complaining?
-
hyc
moneromooo: so scratch my suggestion to use CN/R for wallet KDF
-
sech1
with difficulty chart added:
i.imgur.com/mtSBS1p.png
-
tevador
any explanation of the pattern between 275000 and 355000?
-
sech1
this is normal CN/R pattern
-
sech1
GPU miners split nonces that way
-
sech1
depending on the amount of GPUs in a rig
-
sech1
hence horizontal lines
-
tevador
I'm guessing nothing was visible in the Monero nonce distribution?
-
tevador
it looks like the FPGAs are only ~30 MH/s in total
-
sech1
just looked at top 2 sumo pools. Each of them has ~10 MH/s miner
-
sech1
so 2 individual miners account for 70% of Sumo hashrate
-
sech1
Monero nonce distribution looked fine, at least on this scale of FPGA mining
-
sech1
too subtle to notice
-
sech1
maybe it's even a single miner who spread hashrate between 2 pools
-
hyc
why did difficulty drop so sharply at CN/R introduction? were CN ASIC miners on there before too?
-
sech1
they were on cn/heavy before
-
sech1
so I guess cn/heavy also had some specialized hardware
-
hyc
ah
-
tevador
so many CN tweaks have been made - and all of them ASIC'd
-
hyc
that's what you get with static algorithms ...
-
hyc
personally I'd prefer to see more uniform nonce distribution, and less of these streaks
-
hyc
what's xmrig's nonce pattern look like? also streaky?
-
sech1
This is Monero's nonces:
i.imgur.com/qiZoooA.png
-
sech1
last 2 forks are shown
-
sech1
RandomX pattern is dominated by proxies
-
sech1
so 256 horizontal lines
-
sech1
and a bit thicker line at the bottom - individual workers
-
hyc
so it sounds to me like ASICs are doing the right thing - starting at randomly selected nonces
-
hyc
and GPU miners are being too regimented
-
hyc
I wonder if that means they're using a true hardware RNG
-
Inge-
"they" = asics in that last sentence, hyc ?
-
tevador
-
tevador
another Grin ASIC cancelled
-
hyc
Inge-: yes
-
hyc
tevador what do they mean "GPU ASIC" ?
-
hyc
so basically they're saying their chosen foundry partner was incompetent?
-
hyc
TSMC I presume
-
tevador
or their design was too exotic for the foundry
-
tevador
I guess they call it a GPU ASIC since Grin is mined by GPUs
-
tevador
otherwise it has nothing to do with GPUs
-
hyc
you would think the foundry guys would assess up front whether they can handle the design or not
-
tevador
in any case, RandomX ASIC looks even less likely to be designed
-
gingeropolous
it amazes me after all these years of bitcoin asics screwing over people, that there were enough suckers to buy into another asic preorder
-
hyc
well, they're all getting full refunds, so I wouldn't call 'em suckers unless they don't get their money back
-
hyc
I wonder who the actual foundry is, since TSMC clearly have no problem producing GPUs and CPUs, high complexity stuff
-
cohcho
I thought that mining ASIC is even easier to design than CPU/GPU.
-
tevador
-
hyc
"Go to the ravencoin discord, ask admins to join algo room, and be part of the discussion regarding next algo"
-
cohcho
sech1, can you share code that transform nonce.txt into image?
-
cohcho
I can promise that will not use it for profit.
-
sech1
-
sech1
and the code that creates txt files from RPC json data:
paste.debian.net/1126528
-
sech1
first one is for gnuplot
-
lza_menace
sweet, that's what I came to ask for!
-
jtgrassie
cohcho: pool PR is great
-
jtgrassie
thanks
-
gingeropolous
total miners 28564
-
cohcho
I've just got what they change in xmrig
-
cohcho
(they == botnets)
-
cohcho
b'donate.v2.xmrig.com' replaced with b'127.0.0.1\x00\x00\x00\x00\x00\x00\x00\x00\x00\x00'