-
hyc
-
hyc
we should do something similar - analyze the jobs being issued from the major monero pools
-
hyc
make sure the block hashes their jobs are based on correspond to the current chain tip
-
hyc
it sounds like the level of monitoring they're aiming for could defeat dandelion tho
-
sarang
-
sarang
Comments/suggestions welcome
-
hyc
concise, looks good
-
hyc
did we get any shiny logo artwork? :P
-
sarang
-
monerobux
[REDDIT] triptych needs a logo (self.Monero) | 21 points (88.0%) | 14 comments | Posted by gingeropolous | Created at 2020-08-21 - 02:24:02
-
sarang
good bot
-
sarang
-
hyc
lol
-
hyc
superimposed on a brick wall, looking like street art/tagging, could be cool
-
sarang
-
sarang
The pennyfarthing shows a big ring and a small ring
-
hyc
a bit more classy, definitely
-
hyc
but this is usually what I would envision for the word
thumbs.dreamstime.com/z/medieval-triptych-15742101.jpg
-
hyc
-
hyc
and is, funnily enough, Byzantine
-
hyc
replace the religious portraiture with ... math formulas or something
i.pinimg.com/originals/76/fe/bd/76febd8ad6483679d63eac4dff1bac97.jpg
-
sech1
hyc monitoring mining pools is even easier with RandomX because each pool job must have block height
-
hyc
good point
-
dEBRUYNE
sarang: Good post
-
dEBRUYNE
I wonder if we can slightly modify this statement though -> 'While there are currently no formal plans to deploy Triptych as part of the
-
dEBRUYNE
Monero protocol'
-
sarang
How so?
-
sarang
There are no such plans
-
dEBRUYNE
Perhaps something like 'we're still investigating the feasibility'
-
sarang
That would also be accurate
-
sarang
I could go into details on current limitations, if desired
-
sarang
I mean, there are also no formal plans _not_ to deploy it
-
sarang
shrug
-
sarang
Hopefully the use of careful but accurate terminology will help dispel this nonsense about zero-knowledge proving systems and ring signatures
-
sarang
Triptych is a linkable ring signature built using a zero-knowledge proving system
-
dEBRUYNE
My point is basically that 'no formal plans' can be interpreted as a definite no, which seems a bit negative
-
sarang
Good point
-
sarang
I think your modification helps to clarify, and is still accurate
-
sarang
Should I mention anything in the post about Arcturus?
-
sarang
Arcturus and Triptych have similarities
-
sarang
"While we are still investigating technical details required for a future deployment of Triptych into the Monero protocol, it is very exciting to see the paper accepted for publication!"
-
sarang
^ dEBRUYNE
-
sarang
Multisig is still under consideration, since it's more complex with Triptych/Arcturus/RCT3 than it is in CLSAG/MLSAG
-
sarang
I really hope nobody uses the proof-of-concept code in production without review :/
-
dEBRUYNE
sarang: Yep that looks good
-
dEBRUYNE
Not sure about mentioning Arcturus
-
sarang
Nor am I
-
dEBRUYNE
The benefit probably does not outweigh the potential for confusion
-
sarang
It has the same cryptographic foundation as Triptych, but the security model is different
-
sarang
as are the hardness assumptions
-
sarang
fair enough